TL;DR
A growing number of physical game discs depend on online servers for full functionality. This trend threatens future playability if servers are shut down, raising concerns about game preservation.
Recent testing confirms that a significant portion of physical game discs now require additional downloads to be fully playable, raising concerns about future accessibility. This shift affects the value of owning physical copies, especially as servers and online dependencies are phased out. The trend is documented by DoesItPlay, a community of physical game testers, who have found that over 27% of tested physical releases need downloads to fix bugs or access core content.
Since 2019, the community-led project DoesItPlay has been tracking the functionality of physical game releases across major consoles. Their findings reveal that 27% of tested physical releases require some form of online download to function correctly, with the percentage rising to 34% for PS5 games and 50% for Xbox Series X titles. Many of these games contain only partial data on the disc, with large downloads necessary to access the full experience, such as Doom: The Dark Ages and The Outer Worlds 2.
Furthermore, publishers increasingly implement mandatory online checks or downloads that prevent gameplay without an internet connection. Examples include recent AAA titles like Hogwarts Legacy and Jedi Survivor. The trend is more pronounced on Xbox, where Microsoft is criticized for releasing incomplete physical versions that require frequent downloads or account creation, eroding the offline value of physical media.
Implications for Game Preservation and Ownership
This trend threatens the long-term accessibility of physical games, as many rely on online servers that may be shut down in the future. Owners of physical copies could find their games unplayable once these servers are gone, challenging traditional notions of game ownership and preservation. It also raises questions about the integrity of physical media as a reliable medium for future gameplay, especially as publishers increasingly treat physical releases as incomplete or online-dependent.
Rioddas External CD/DVD Drive for Laptop, USB 3.0 CD DVD Player Portable +/-RW Burner CD ROM Reader Writer Disk Duplicator Compatible with Laptop Desktop PC Windows Apple Mac Pro MacBook Linux
Plug & Play. Easy to use, powered by USB port. No external driver or power adapter needed. Simply…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Rise of Online-Dependent Physical Game Releases
Over recent years, the gaming industry has shifted toward digital and online-dependent models, even for physical releases. The initial appeal of owning a physical disc—full offline access—has diminished as publishers embed mandatory downloads, patches, or online checks. This change is partly driven by the desire to combat piracy, enable day-one patches, and push digital sales, but it also risks rendering physical copies obsolete if servers are shut down or updates become unavailable.
Historically, physical media was seen as a safeguard against digital obsolescence, but recent trends show that even physical copies are increasingly dependent on online infrastructure. This evolution has sparked concern among preservation advocates and dedicated collectors, who worry about future access to their games.
“There is a clear trend that physical releases are increasingly treated with ignorance from larger companies. Physical games would never die unless someone like Sony deliberately kills them.”
— Clemens Itsel, owner of DoesItPlay
Seagate 2TB Game Drive for Xbox | USB 3.0 (STKX2000400)
BUILD YOUR GAME VAULT 2TB of capacity to build the ultimate Game Vault without sacrificing titles. Store your…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Extent of Future Unplayability Due to Server Shutdowns
It is not yet clear how many of these physically owned games will become unplayable if servers or online services are discontinued. The timeline for server shutdowns and the impact on existing physical copies remain uncertain, and some games may still be playable offline for years to come.
neotidy Playing Card Storage Box Set of 6, Clear Plastic Playing Card Cases Organizer with Snap Lid, Mixed Sizes Card Game Storage for UN* Cards, Standard Decks, Trading Cards, Card Game Holder Case
Mixed Size Storage System – Organize Every Deck with Ease: Upgrade your playing card storage with a smart…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Monitoring Industry Trends and Preservation Efforts
Industry observers and preservation advocates are watching how publishers handle future updates and online dependencies. Efforts to develop tools or methods to preserve offline versions of games may increase. Additionally, gamers and collectors are encouraged to consider the online dependencies of physical titles before purchase.
Siveit CD Case, DVD Case Holder 96 Capacity Hard Plastic CD DVD Disc Cases Storage Binder Wallet for Car Home Office Travel (Black)
Large Capacity: Siveit CD case can store 96 CDs/DVDs and keep them well organized, saving you more space….
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Can I still play my physical game if servers go offline?
It depends on whether the game requires online access for core functionality. Many recent releases may become unplayable or limited without online connectivity or downloads.
Are all physical games now online-dependent?
No, some physical releases still contain complete game data and can be played offline, but the trend toward online dependence is increasing, especially on newer consoles.
What can consumers do to protect their game collections?
Consumers should research whether their physical games require online servers or downloads and consider digital backups or supporting publishers committed to offline preservation.
Will future consoles prevent offline play of physical discs?
This is uncertain. While current trends show increasing online dependencies, some platforms may continue to support offline play, but industry shifts could change this landscape.
Is there any way to preserve games that depend on online servers?
Preservation efforts are ongoing, including community-led projects to archive game data and develop tools for offline access, but these are not yet widespread or officially supported.
Source: Hacker News
